Knol as a teaching resource
July 26th, 2008I’m really excited about the Google Knol concept, and I’ve been thinking about how I’d like to use it as a teaching resource. Wikipedia has a problem in that at any moment incorrect or false information can be edited into an entry. Whilst the owners say that the democratic and widespread nature of Wikipedia means those errors will be corrected and picked up by others, at any snapshot point in time if one of your students goes to read a Wikipedia article, they may unintentionally include errors that haven’t been picked up in their reading.
Now, of course students should be developing critical thinking skills when they read any source of information, but encyclopedias are presented as authoritative, precisely because they are supposed to give an accurate overview of a topic. Hence the ‘critical thinking’ guard can easily be let down by students when using Wikipedia. Consequently, I rarely recommend students include Wikipedia in their reading.
Now, I confess I do use Wikipedia. If I want to get a quick glimpse at a topic before I begin any serious research on it, I’ll scan through Wikipedia. But I certainly do not rely on it as my only source of information. If it’s a subject I know little about, I am extremely guarded about what I read there.
With Knols, however, a teacher is able to write their own entries on particular topics that they may want to make accessible to their students. I have dozens and dozens of lecture notes and articles that I have written on topics over the years, everything from the use of daraba in the ‘beating’ verse of the Qur’an, to conversion patterns of Australians who become Muslims, to the relationship between rationality and religious faith. At the moment they are sitting on my computer (and backup disks) but I am planning to craft them into Knols so that I can use them as teaching resources down the track. Very exciting stuff!
Join the 
A Melburnian Muslim convert blogs religion, academia and life in general.









